Despite ant opinions to the contrary, I would like to invite one and all to participate in the conversations within the missouri forums. We need as much support as possible from all positions and persons. IMHO it is very wise to gather as much information as possible on a subject so when one tries to represent such an opinion to guest to invite here or garner support for the causes we seek to change, that voice can have at least collective input as a knowledge base before it is expressed in a manner that might otherwise be flawed.
IMHO there was no argument on this thread, what appeared to be dynamically different positions after the discussions are found to be not quite so different and are influenced by different histories and backgrounds. As a college professor I can assure you this leads to improved understanding not only of the opposing view but at times even your own.
I did a 2.5 hour lecture last evening and made 4 mistakes on a subject that I am indeed an authority on, I caught them and was able to correct them. In the past I have had student catch them as well and one thing I have had great feed back on is my wiliness to acknowledge those mistakes instead of “trying to bullshirt my way out of them” which is the experience they have had with other instructors.
This “argument” as you refer to it has lent itself to progress. While I can not speak for marshaul I will any way and state that I think that he sees my position differently than he did from the beginning and while he does not agree with it, he understands why it was developed and does not consider it totally unreasonable as he may have from the beginning. I also will certainly acknowledge that because of my own history and knowledge base I gave no consideration to how others thoughts might be developed based upon a significantly different regulating history and I can understand how his opinion of my opinion was strong and opposing.
None of that is dependent on his or my location and I found it to be good conversation and would invite anyone from anywhere to join in on it and I have no understanding of why anyone would want to quash such conversations from occurring, that simply makes no sense and seems extremely narrow minded.