M1Gunr, Thanks for the quick response. And thank you for answering my questions. I do appreciate the help in this situation.
I would like to make one response to your comment about giving up rights. While I cannot argue with you, and do believe that you are correct in your assessment of the type of situation described, I believe that it is the better path to follow. For the following reasons. Is it better to stand on your rights and refuse to cooperate with an officer who is being polite and simply trying to ensure the public safety? His job btw. Or is it better to cooperate thereby showing that you are a law abiding citizen, not trying to do anything shady and simply trying to exercise the rights guaranteed to you by law? If the officer was just doing his job and was being polite about it your refusal might give them "probable cause" to detain you and run the serial number anyway, without your permission. If you aren't doing anything illegal, you aren't carrying an illegal gun and the gun was legally purchased, never used in the commission of a crime and you are allowed to own a firearm, what is the harm in letting the officer in question do their job ensuring not only your safety, but the safety of those around you?
"What legal/Moral right if I am doing nothing wrong?"
The officer has the authority, the legal right and the moral right to draw their firearm in defense of citizens, to stop someone from breaking a law, or to assist in the apprehension of a person suspected of breaking a law. (someone please correct me if I am wrong on that, but that is the way it was explained to me by a friend who is also a police officer) The problem with this is that it is up to their subjective judgement. See my comment above about "probable cause". I would rather not get into a situation where a police officer even remembers that he has a gun on his hip while dealing with me. To avoid that, I will happily answer any questions I consider reasonable and which do not actually violate my civil rights. No you don't have to answer, but I would suggest to anyone who is in a situation like this, think long and hard about whether or not you are willing to live with the consequences of not answering, and if the point in question is truly worth the hassle.
Also, in my own defense, in CA when OC was legal you had to submit to a safety check anytime you were stopped by an officer. So my thought processes might be a little warped by that.
Finally I don't see answering questions as giving up rights. He might be asking to see if he knows as much as you about the current laws, which in most cases he probably doesn't. He might be asking to ensure that you know what you are doing and that you are doing it correctly and safely, so that he can educate you if necessary. Both situations are perfectly reasonable and, frankly, I would welcome encounters like this.
Just my two cents.
Again thanks for the help. I appreciate the feedback and the differing point of view on this topic. Unfortunately you get just as many different opinions as there are people who are both for and against OC. I appreciate your candor and response.